Anna Mae Routledge & Sarah Smyth
Apr 17th, 2009 | By Jeremy D. Bonfiglio | Category: Harper's Island, Questions With...
For those keeping track, the body count on CBS’ new murder mystery “Harper’s Island” is clipping along at a fast pace. There have been five deaths - not including deer - after just two episodes of the 13-episode, short-run series that follows a group of family and friends who travel to a secluded island for a destination wedding.
In the latest installment, Sarah Smyth ( “The Covenant”) who played bridesmaid and socialite Lucy Daramour and Anna Mae Routledge (”Supernatural,” “Psych”) who played the needy island outcast Kelly Seaver met their untimely ends in classic slasher-film fashion. We caught up with Smyth and Routledge to talk about their roles, their death scenes and their insights into just how the mystery will unfold.
Question: Sarah, I think the first thing everyone wants to know is, was Gigi your little toy dog spared the same fate as Lucy?
Sarah Smyth: (laughter) I don’t really know what happens to her but I suspect Gigi is the killer so I think she’ll be around until the end.
Q: Anna Mae, we just started getting into your character last night and then you were gone. Were you surprised when you read the script that you would be gone by episode’s end?
Anna Mae Routledge: You know, I was. My character really got to go through her entire life story in one episode. You had some redemption, love or lust and then she was gone, which was kind of sad.
Q: How much did you know about your character’s fate going into the project and when did you find out about your death scenes?
SS: When I got cast we didn’t know how long we would make it. One of the producers told me at the end of filming the first episode that Lucy wouldn’t make it to the third.
AMR: When I was cast even my agent told me ‘just try to stay alive.’ I also found out at the end of the first episode when the new scripts came around. You sort of just thumb through it to see what happens.
Q: What did you think about your death scenes? We were sort of shocked by the discovery of Kelly’s body hanging in her house and then we got to see Lucy fall into a pit and set on fire in another brutal death scene.
AMR: I’m really impressed with the way the writers are crafting these stories. I really thought with all that character development that Kelly would stick around, that somehow she’d survive. So when you see her there it was a surprise but I was also surprised that Lucy went so quickly.
SS: As soon as I was told I would be carrying a small dog around I knew I was doomed (laughter). It’s ‘let’s kill off Paris Hilton.’ I think my death scene was really cool actually. You really got to see what happened to her.
Q: I know the killer’s identity is being kept secret but are there any personal predictions you want to share on who the culprit might be?
AMR: I really have no idea. Right now my bet is on J.D. Dunn. He’s just a really dark character.
SS: I don’t know. My guess was Gigi was going to be the killer. If it’s not then maybe Mr. Wellington. He seems really shady. There’s just too many possibilities.
Q: What’s next for the two of you? Where else can we expect to see you?
SS: I’m in a film that was just released in theaters on April 3 called “Alien Trespass.”
AMR: I have a film that comes out in June called “I Love You Beth Cooper” with Hayden Panettiere (”Heroes”).
SS: I also have an upcoming guest spot on “Smallville” in an episode called “Injustice.” Let’s just say I play a character who’s electrifying (Editor’s note: Rumor has it that she’ll be playing Livewire also from the DC Comics universe).
AMR: Who knows? You might just find me hanging around.



